To upgrade, or not to upgrade?

This is a thread from @gregory’s great post on the size of a property and if it’s worth having an extra room. I’m hoping for some wisdom here.

https://community.rask.com.au/c/australian-property/would-or-did-you-buy-a-home-with-a-dedicated-guest-spare-room


We went with 3x1x1 (a weatherboard shack that we gutted and renovated - it was a dive when we bought it). We both work from home a bit, have animals, a boat, a turkey, two cars and plan a family. My family stay often but it’s uncomfortable. Now we are left with a decision:

1) a $350,000 move-out renovation (slightly at risk of overcapitalising / eating into our equity buffer). It would become a 4x2x2 or bigger.

2) do a $600,000 upgrade (which is a big deal for us) into a 5x3x2 on a few acres.

Problem is, we’re likely heading into kids. So we’re scrambling to get the financial house in order before we upgrade. I don’t much like the idea of an even bigger mortgage on one income (admittedly, I have 3-4 sources of income nowadays - but it’s still dependent on me).

Does anyone have some lived experience? Take a v plunge to a bigger place now (and cop the interest) or wait?